500 Migrants feared dead off coast of Malta, 11 survivors, UPDATE!

15.09.2014 / 18:08 / 300 nautical miles south east of Malta

Following the International Organisation for Migration (IOM) and collected testimonies of survivors, some 500 migrants are feared dead, after their boat sank in the Mediterranean Sea last week after it had left Egypt on the 6th of September. There are only eleven known survivors in total who, clinging onto floating aids for days, were rescued by different vessels.

Following the IOM, the survivors report of an intentional sinking of their vessel by smugglers:

"The survivors told IOM Tuesday that they already had been forced to change boats three times. When they refused a fourth switch - because they felt the smaller vessel was unsafe – an violent argument ensued. The smugglers threatened that if the passengers did not board the smaller boat they would be returned to Egypt, the survivors told IOM. The migrants persisted saying they would rather return than board the smaller boat. At this stage, according to testimony from four of six survivors, the ten smugglers, said to be Palestinian and Egyptian, began yelling and throwing sticks at the migrants. The smuggler’s vessel approached the boat with migrants some of whom managed to jump into the smaller boat. Witnesses say the smugglers forced them in the water and then rammed the bigger boat. It began to sink immediately while the smugglers stayed in the area until they were certain that the migrant’s vessel had sunk, witnesses said."

IOM's director general, William Lacy Swing called the "numbers dying off Europe's coasts [...] shocking and unacceptable".

(See: http://www.iom.int/cms/en/sites/iom/home/news-and-views/press-briefing-notes/pbn-2014b/pbn-listing/iom-says-new-witnesses-provide-f.html)

The passengers on board were mainly from Palestine, Sudan, Syria and Egypt. Some of the survivors were brought to Sicily and others to Crete. The IOM estimates that there could have been up to 100 children on board.

While the IOM speaks of a case of mass murder, they mainly blame traffickers and only then mention the ever-more restrictive migration routes to Europe. The estimated number of 2500-3000 deaths, which is presumably much higher, cannot be dissociated from processes of externalisation and militarisation of EU borders that leave hardly any other options than to travel on unseaworthy and precarious vessels. The 500 lives lost are, once again, a direct consequence of EU border practices and policies.

The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein also reacted, calling for the "Mediterranean mass murderers" to be brought to justice. He stated: “The callous act of deliberately ramming a boat full of hundreds of defenceless people is a crime that must not go unpunished. If the survivors’ accounts are indeed true – and they appear all too credible – we are looking at what amounts to mass murder in the Mediterranean.”

"It is the duty of States to investigate such atrocious crimes, bring the perpetrators to justice, and even more importantly to do more to prevent them from happening in the first place. All the countries in the Mediterranean must make a concerted effort to clamp down on the smugglers who are exploiting one of the most vulnerable groups on the planet and endangering their lives, virtually on a daily basis, purely for financial gain.”

http://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=15069&LangID=E

Amnesty International has reacted to the incident by calling EU member states' responses to refugee crises shameful: "European leaders want to prevent people from reaching Europe at any cost, forcing desperate people to take more hazardous routes. [...] EU leaders have been unwilling to open safe and legal ways for refugees and migrants to reach Europe, and until they change their stance more lives will continue to be lost at sea.”

(See: http://www.amnesty.org/en/news/libya-migrant-boat-sinking-highlights-need-eu-action-2014-09-15)

UPDATE:
Following accounts of survivors, doubt is growing about the version that the IOM has provided concerning the incident. The Syrian survivor Doaa could not confirm the IOM version that traffickers intentionally rammed the boat (see Handelsblatt news report).

The Algerian newspaper El Watan also provides a different version (see FFM report). The crew of the container vessel who rescued some of the survivors and who conducted initial interviews with them, suggests that there were two refugee vessels, one with about 300-400 passengers and one with about 30 passengers. When the smaller vessel started to capsise, it turned to the larger vessel. A collision occurred through which the larger vessel was so badly damaged that it capsised as well. Following FFM, this account contradicts the macabre version offered by the IOM.

Furthermore, the investigation of the shipwreck is conducted by strictly isolating the survivors. It is not clear whether there are 9 or maybe even 20 survivors (in police custory in Greece, Malta or Italy). The bodies that were retrieved were burried without being photographed. The Italian authorities fail to respond to calls voiced (mainly)in Gaza to receive information about the identities of the survivors and the dead.

http://ffm-online.org/2014/09/17/schiffskatastrophe-massenmord-es-waren-2-fluechtlingsboote-el-watan/
Last update: 16:14 Sep 20, 2014
Credibility: UP DOWN 0
Layers »
  • Border police patrols
     
    While the exact location of patrols is of course constantly changing, this line indicates the approximate boundary routinely patrolled by border guards’ naval assets. In the open sea, it usually correspond to the outer extent of the contiguous zone, the area in which “State may exercise the control necessary to prevent infringement of its customs, fiscal, immigration or sanitary laws” (UNCLOS, art. 33). Data source: interviews with border police officials.
  • Coastal radars
     
    Approximate radar beam range covered by coastal radars operating in the frame of national marine traffic monitoring systems. The actual beam depends from several different parameters (including the type of object to be detected). Data source: Finmeccanica.
  • Exclusive Economic Zone
     
    Maritime area beyond and adjacent to the territorial sea in which the coastal state exercises sovereign rights for the purposes of exploring and exploiting, conserving and managing the natural resources, whether living or non-living, the seabed and its subsoil and the superjacent waters. Its breadth is 200 nautical miles from the straight baselines from which the territorial sea is measured (UNCLOS, Arts. 55, 56 and 57). Data source: Juan Luis Suárez de Vivero, Atlas of the European Seas and Oceans
  • Frontex operations
     
    Frontex has, in the past few years, carried out several sea operations at the maritime borders of the EU. The blue shapes indicate the approximate extend of these operations. Data source: Migreurop Altas.
  • Mobile phone coverage
     
    Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM) network coverage. Data source: Collins Mobile Coverage.
  • Oil and gas platforms
     
    Oil and gas platforms in the Mediterranean. Data source:
  • Search and Rescue Zone
     
    An area of defined dimensions within which a given state is has the responsibility to co-ordinate Search and Rescue operations, i.e. the search for, and provision of aid to, persons, ships or other craft which are, or are feared to be, in distress or imminent danger. Data source: IMO availability of search and rescue (SAR) services - SAR.8/Circ.3, 17 June 2011.
  • Territorial Waters
     
    A belt of sea (usually extending up to 12 nautical miles) upon which the sovereignty of a coastal State extends (UNCLOS, Art. 2). Data source: Juan Luis Suárez de Vivero, Atlas of the European Seas and Oceans

Related Reports

00:00 May 03, 2020 / Central Mediterranean Kms
02/05: 68 people left from Zuara, rescued to Lampedusa
09:01 Jul 09, 2015 / Central Mediterranean Sea Kms
Approximately 580 people in distress on two vessels in the Central Med, rescued
18:16 Aug 24, 2014 / North of Libyan coast Kms
24 dead, more fatalities feared